Exploring the possible avenues of the creation of a "Fighter's Union"
WKR has long thought a fighter's union or guild --plus the subsequent collective bargaining agreement that would come with organized labor-- would be in the best interest of the UFC. Zuffa will never ever let a union form most likely doesn't agree with WKR's assessment.
That reality has often left WKR pondering the question: How could a fighter's union or guild form?
The most obvious narrative would be a potential labor dispute with a powerful star. The history of most major U.S. sports leagues followed this script. A big name athlete challenges the controlling contract of his team in court and wins. This is usually coupled with a popular athlete unionizing his peers.
Such drastic changes in the status-quo usually take years if not decades. The National Basketball Players Association was formed in 1954 but it wasn't until 1964 that the first CBA was agreed upon and not until 1976 that players defeated the "Reserve Clause" in court. The "Reserve Clause" basically stated that the player was property of their team for life and could not leave the team unless they chose to release, sell or trade that player (and his contract). The clause further stated that a team could renew a contract even if the player would not sign it.
With regards to the UFC there is no "Reserve Clause" that could cause legal dispute but the "Championship Clause" and the Exclusive Promotional and Ancillary Rights Agreement --where fighters sign over there eternal rights to "name, sobriquet, voice, persona, signature, likeness and/or biography."-- could be the kindle to start a legal fire.
Randy Couture's legal battle with the UFC briefly appeared to begin the process of challenging certain aspects of Zuffa contracts, a possible first step towards a fighter's union. However this legal challenge was short lived as Couture re-entered the organization to fight Brock Lesnar. This incident highlighted the immense temporal sacrifice an individual athlete would have to make for the chance of legal victory.
The difficulties that Randy Couture faced appeared to close the door, at least in the present, of a star taking Zuffa to court.
Perhaps the star-legal battle path is the wrong direction to expect a fighter's guild to emerge from. Perhaps organized labor will come from fighter gyms and teams.
Fighter teams are already a thorn in the side of the UFC. Bloody Elbow recently detailed the difficulty Dana White is facing when trying to have team mates fight each other inside the UFC.
Why are fighter teams a possible road map for organized labor?
It is quite simple really. The high cost of training has lead many fighters to band together in gyms that provide services outside of mere facilities to work out in. Take American Kickboxing Academy for instance. This gym provides lawyers, managers and sponsors for the fighters that pay to be apart of the gym. In a sense AKA is a mini-fighter's guild already functioning and dealing with the UFC. While fighter's are still free to make independent decisions they are all providing support for one another without prejudice to what tier a fighter is currently in e.g. local promotion vs. Strikeforce vs. UFC.
The formation of "teams" --that provide ancillary services in addition to training partners-- is a trend that is occurring across the landscape of MMA. The rise of the "team" unit is an unique moment in combat sports and could provide the pathway to organized labor.
While WKR is clearly playing the role of a "futurist" it's still an interesting grass roots development. As fighter's coalesce around gyms their leverage increases. Of course it will still take a serious legal challenge or catalyst event to push the "team" system into open cooperation to achieve a fighter's guild.
0 recs |
7 comments
|
Comments
Zak...
This is not the way to go about getting credentialed for UFC events =)
watchkalibrun.com
by Nick Becker on Aug 19, 2009 1:15 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Lol, I dont think they are giving them to me anyways :-p
watchkalibrun.com
by Zak Woods on Aug 19, 2009 3:43 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
In all seriousness
If the UFC takes a hard-line stance and begins insisting on fighters from the same camp facing each other then that could very well be the catalyst for the creation of a fighter’s union.
In that respect, I could see some potentially affected camps (ex: AKA, Black House, Jackson’s Submission Fighting) banding together and this issue actually gaining some traction.
watchkalibrun.com
by Nick Becker on Aug 19, 2009 1:30 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
as of this moment there is really no reason for some of the guys to fight one another
watchkalibrun.com
by Zak Woods on Aug 19, 2009 3:44 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Eventually
…a fighters guild or union, definitely.
…Blog owners/writers getting UFC credentials. (You guys dont’t get them right..? Nick B. was busting your chops..)
Also, i understand same camp guys not wanting to compete against one another, but business is business. the discussion has been kicking around for a while but the machida/silva thing is really blowing it up. Like Zak said, at the moment things are fine.
by MBreezy on Aug 19, 2009 3:50 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
yeah we dont get them
The team concept is unique and that is part of the reason why a “UFC guild” would be good. It could help get rid of some of those feelings of fealty.
watchkalibrun.com
by Zak Woods on Aug 19, 2009 3:59 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Exactly
Things are fine now and there is no need for these fighters to face one another but when if Silva and Machida are #1 and #2 in the Light-Heavyweight division and the UFC starts to force the issue thenwe could see camps banding together to protest.
The UFC’s insistence on fighters from the same camp facing each other could be the proverbial straw that breaks the camel’s back in terms of unionizing.
Don’t get me wrong, I want to see the best fight the best regardless so as a fan of the sport I am on the UFC’s side of the issue, but realistically the consequences of such actions could dramatically change the sport as we know it.
watchkalibrun.com
by Nick Becker on Aug 19, 2009 5:09 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs

by 















